Ever been in a conversation where you felt like your brain was melting? You know the kind. You’re making a point — calmly, rationally, maybe even with a dash of charm — and suddenly you’re drowning in a tidal wave of nonsense. Personal attacks. Wild conclusions. The type of logic that makes you wonder if the other person recently suffered a head injury. It’s infuriating. It makes you want to flip a table and scream: ‍ ‍ But here’s the thing: Sometimes you can’t avoid these people. Maybe it’s your boss. Maybe it’s a relative you only see at holidays. Maybe it’s the guy in line at the grocery store who thinks he’s the second coming of Aristotle because he read one headline on Facebook. For these moments, you need tools. Not to “win” the argument — because half the time, winning just means wasting more energy — but to keep your sanity and not lose faith in the species. Here are 8 of the sneakiest logic traps people use and how to dismantle them without losing your mind (or your soul). ‍ 1. Ad Hominem The Classic Cheap Shot. Instead of debating your point, they debate you. Because why confront a real argument when they can take a swing at your character? Example: You: “I think this company should adopt more sustainable practices. ”Them: “Oh, coming from the guy who still drives a gas guzzler?” Counter: “Me driving a gas guzzler doesn’t change the fact that sustainability is important. Maybe let’s focus on the idea instead of my car.” Translation: Stop making this about me. My hypocrisy (real or imagined) doesn’t make your argument better. ‍ 2. Straw Man Building a Scarecrow, Then Setting It on Fire. This is when someone takes what you said, twists it into a ridiculous caricature, and then torches that nonsense instead of your actual point. Example: You: “I think remote work has its benefits. ”Them: “So you just want everyone to sit at home in pajamas and never talk to another human again?” Counter: “I didn’t say that. Remote work doesn’t mean social isolation. It means flexibility. Two very different things.” Translation: Don’t shove words in my mouth and then pretend you’re the hero for chewing them up. 3. Slippery Slope The “Everything Will Collapse” Argument. One small change, and suddenly we’re tumbling into the apocalypse. Because why deal with nuance when you can predict doom? Example: You: “We should allow flexible work hours. ”Them: “Yeah, and next thing you know, no one will work at all, and society will crumble.” Counter: “Flexible hours don’t mean people stop working. It means they work smarter. Let’s not jump to Mad Max conclusions.” Translation: Calm down, Nostradamus. One step forward doesn’t always lead to a cliff. 4. Bandwagon Fallacy If Everyone Else Jumped Off a Bridge… This one’s like peer pressure in argument form. Just because everyone believes it doesn’t make it true. Example: Them: “Everyone I know says this diet works, so it must be good for you.” Counter: “A bunch of people believing something doesn’t make it true. Everyone used to think the Earth was flat too.” Translation: Popularity is a terrible judge of truth. Ask any middle school kid. 5. Appeal to Authority Because the “Expert” Said So. Dragging in a big name who has zero relevance to the topic. Example: Them: “My yoga instructor says this is the best investment strategy.” Counter: “Your yoga instructor might know how to do a perfect downward dog, but I don’t think they’re Warren Buffett.” Translation: Cool story. Now let’s hear from someone who knows what they’re talking about. 6. False Dichotomy Pick a Side. There Are Only Two. This is when they boil a complex issue down to two extreme choices. It’s lazy thinking disguised as decisiveness. Example: Them: “You’re either a cat person or a dog person.” Counter: “Or — hear me out — I can like both. Or neither. Because life isn’t a Disney movie.” Translation: There’s more than one flavor of ice cream. Stop making me choose between vanilla and vanilla. ‍ 7. Red Herring Look Over There! They throw in something completely irrelevant to distract you from the actual topic. It’s the argument equivalent of a toddler pointing at a shiny object. Example: You: “I think the camera quality on this phone isn’t great. ”Them: “Yeah, but feel how sleek the design is!” Counter: “The design is nice, but we’re talking about the camera. Stay with me here.” Translation: Stop trying to change the subject. I’m not that easy to distract. ‍ 8. False Cause Two Things Happened, So They Must Be Related. Just because two things happen together doesn’t mean one caused the other. Correlation is not causation. Example: Them: “Every time I wear this shirt, my team wins. It’s my lucky shirt!” Counter: “Or maybe your team is just good at sports. Your shirt isn’t part of the lineup.” Translation: Coincidences happen. Your shirt is not magic. Sorry. How to Survive These Conversations Without Losing Your Mind Stay Calm: Getting emotional is like handing them a free pass to dismiss you. Breathe. Channel your inner stoic.


Listen Hard: Make sure you actually understand what they’re saying before you respond. Misunderstanding them gives them ammo.


Be Prepared: Know these fallacies like the back of your hand. The more you spot them, the less they’ll trip you up.


Keep It Simple: Clear arguments win. Complexity is just noise. Bonus Tip: If the conversation is going nowhere and your sanity is at stake, walk away. NOE ONE ever looked back on their life and thought, “I wish I argued with more idiots.” Final Thought These tools won’t just help you in arguments. They’ll help you avoid the pointless ones. And in a world where arguing online is practically a hobby, that’s a superpower. So go forth, defend your sanity, and maybe — just maybe — help create a world where people think before they speak. Or not. At least you’ll be smarter. Until next time✌️ Ben. ‍ Ever been in a conversation where you felt like your brain was melting? You know the kind. You’re making a point — calmly, rationally, maybe even with a dash of charm — and suddenly you’re drowning in a tidal wave of nonsense. Personal attacks. Wild conclusions. The type of logic that makes you wonder if the other person recently suffered a head injury. It’s infuriating. It makes you want to flip a table and scream: ‍ ‍ But here’s the thing: Sometimes you can’t avoid these people. Maybe it’s your boss. Maybe it’s a relative you only see at holidays. Maybe it’s the guy in line at the grocery store who thinks he’s the second coming of Aristotle because he read one headline on Facebook. For these moments, you need tools. Not to “win” the argument — because half the time, winning just means wasting more energy — but to keep your sanity and not lose faith in the species. Here are 8 of the sneakiest logic traps people use and how to dismantle them without losing your mind (or your soul). 8 of the sneakiest logic 8 of the sneakiest logic ‍ 1. Ad Hominem 1. Ad Hominem The Classic Cheap Shot. The Classic Cheap Shot. Instead of debating your point, they debate you . Because why confront a real argument when they can take a swing at your character? you Example: You: “I think this company should adopt more sustainable practices. ”Them: “Oh, coming from the guy who still drives a gas guzzler?” Example: Counter: “Me driving a gas guzzler doesn’t change the fact that sustainability is important. Maybe let’s focus on the idea instead of my car.” Counter: Translation: Stop making this about me. My hypocrisy (real or imagined) doesn’t make your argument better. Translation: ‍ 2. Straw Man 2. Straw Man Building a Scarecrow, Then Setting It on Fire. Building a Scarecrow, Then Setting It on Fire. This is when someone takes what you said, twists it into a ridiculous caricature, and then torches that nonsense instead of your actual point. Example: You: “I think remote work has its benefits. ”Them: “So you just want everyone to sit at home in pajamas and never talk to another human again?” Example: Counter: “I didn’t say that. Remote work doesn’t mean social isolation. It means flexibility. Two very different things.” Counter: Translation: Don’t shove words in my mouth and then pretend you’re the hero for chewing them up. Translation: 3. Slippery Slope 3. Slippery Slope The “Everything Will Collapse” Argument. The “Everything Will Collapse” Argument. One small change, and suddenly we’re tumbling into the apocalypse. Because why deal with nuance when you can predict doom? Example: You: “We should allow flexible work hours. ”Them: “Yeah, and next thing you know, no one will work at all, and society will crumble.” Example: Counter: “Flexible hours don’t mean people stop working. It means they work smarter. Let’s not jump to Mad Max conclusions.” Counter: Translation: Calm down, Nostradamus. One step forward doesn’t always lead to a cliff. Translation: 4. Bandwagon Fallacy 4. Bandwagon Fallacy If Everyone Else Jumped Off a Bridge… If Everyone Else Jumped Off a Bridge… This one’s like peer pressure in argument form. Just because everyone believes it doesn’t make it true. Example: Them: “Everyone I know says this diet works, so it must be good for you.” Example: Counter: “A bunch of people believing something doesn’t make it true. Everyone used to think the Earth was flat too.” Counter: Translation: Popularity is a terrible judge of truth. Ask any middle school kid. Translation: 5. Appeal to Authority 5. Appeal to Authority Because the “Expert” Said So. Because the “Expert” Said So. Dragging in a big name who has zero relevance to the topic. Example: Them: “My yoga instructor says this is the best investment strategy.” Example: Counter: “Your yoga instructor might know how to do a perfect downward dog, but I don’t think they’re Warren Buffett.” Counter: Translation: Cool story. Now let’s hear from someone who knows what they’re talking about. Translation: 6. False Dichotomy 6. False Dichotomy Pick a Side. There Are Only Two. Pick a Side. There Are Only Two. This is when they boil a complex issue down to two extreme choices. It’s lazy thinking disguised as decisiveness. Example: Them: “You’re either a cat person or a dog person.” Example: Counter: “Or — hear me out — I can like both . Or neither. Because life isn’t a Disney movie.” Counter: both Translation: There’s more than one flavor of ice cream. Stop making me choose between vanilla and vanilla. Translation: ‍ 7. Red Herring 7. Red Herring Look Over There! Look Over There! They throw in something completely irrelevant to distract you from the actual topic. It’s the argument equivalent of a toddler pointing at a shiny object. Example: You: “I think the camera quality on this phone isn’t great. ”Them: “Yeah, but feel how sleek the design is!” Example: Counter: “The design is nice, but we’re talking about the camera. Stay with me here.” Counter: Translation: Stop trying to change the subject. I’m not that easy to distract. Translation: ‍ 8. False Cause 8. False Cause Two Things Happened, So They Must Be Related. Two Things Happened, So They Must Be Related. Just because two things happen together doesn’t mean one caused the other. Correlation is not causation. Example: Them: “Every time I wear this shirt, my team wins. It’s my lucky shirt!” Example: Counter: “Or maybe your team is just good at sports. Your shirt isn’t part of the lineup.” Counter: Translation: Coincidences happen. Your shirt is not magic. Sorry. Translation: How to Survive These Conversations Without Losing Your Mind How to Survive These Conversations Without Losing Your Mind Stay Calm: Getting emotional is like handing them a free pass to dismiss you. Breathe. Channel your inner stoic. Listen Hard: Make sure you actually understand what they’re saying before you respond. Misunderstanding them gives them ammo. Be Prepared: Know these fallacies like the back of your hand. The more you spot them, the less they’ll trip you up. Keep It Simple: Clear arguments win. Complexity is just noise. Stay Calm: Getting emotional is like handing them a free pass to dismiss you. Breathe. Channel your inner stoic. Stay Calm: Getting emotional is like handing them a free pass to dismiss you. Breathe. Channel your inner stoic. Stay Calm: Listen Hard: Make sure you actually understand what they’re saying before you respond. Misunderstanding them gives them ammo. Listen Hard: Make sure you actually understand what they’re saying before you respond. Misunderstanding them gives them ammo. Listen Hard: actually Be Prepared: Know these fallacies like the back of your hand. The more you spot them, the less they’ll trip you up. Be Prepared: Know these fallacies like the back of your hand. The more you spot them, the less they’ll trip you up. Be Prepared: Keep It Simple: Clear arguments win. Complexity is just noise. Keep It Simple: Clear arguments win. Complexity is just noise. Keep It Simple: Bonus Tip: If the conversation is going nowhere and your sanity is at stake, walk away. Bonus Tip: NOE ONE ever looked back on their life and thought, “I wish I argued with more idiots.” “I wish I argued with more idiots.” Final Thought Final Thought These tools won’t just help you in arguments. They’ll help you avoid the pointless ones . avoid the pointless ones avoid And in a world where arguing online is practically a hobby, that’s a superpower. So go forth, defend your sanity, and maybe — just maybe — help create a world where people think before they speak. Or not. At least you’ll be smarter. you’ll Until next time✌️ Ben. ‍

Ditch The Resolutions & Become Unf*ckwithable This Year

I’m 37, Emotionally Immature, and the Road Didn’t Fix It

Get the Overthinker’s Mastery Guide

Too Long; Didn't Read

Boost your HackerNoon story @ $159.99! 🚀

Easily Win Arguments By Avoiding These 8 Logic Traps

About Author

Comments

TOPICS

THIS ARTICLE WAS FEATURED IN

Related Stories

Untitled Story

A “Don’t Do” List Can Change Your Life

Everything You've Been Told About Passion is a Lie

My Plan to Make a Million Dollars Writing Online

Standing Out is Overrated: You Should Just Conform Instead

Don't Waste Your Time Watching Sports

A “Don’t Do” List Can Change Your Life

Everything You've Been Told About Passion is a Lie

My Plan to Make a Million Dollars Writing Online

Standing Out is Overrated: You Should Just Conform Instead

Don't Waste Your Time Watching Sports

Light-Mode

Classic

Newspaper

Dark-Mode

Neon Noir

Minty

HN StartUps